Indianapolis Metro, Indiana

John-Michael Polley

Creative Director / Art Director

I turn briefs into brand-true work at any scale, from a brokerage's first in-house agency to 3,000-plus-square-foot public murals.

See the workResumes (PDF)

Back Home Again, Monon 116th Street tunnel, Carmel, Indiana

Selected work

2021 · Monon Greenway, City Center Drive tunnel · Carmel, Indiana · 3,100 sq ft

Ethereal Rhapsody

Role: Creative direction and production, O.N.E. Consulting. I brought in Jordan Elsey to vectorize Carmel High School artist Caroline Hammonds' music-themed design, then led scale-up, printing, and installation, leaving color out of the reachable zone so students could hand-paint it like a giant coloring book. Unveiled September 27, 2021.

Press: Current in Carmel · City of Carmel · Carmel Monthly · Jessup Manufacturing TexWalk® case study

Ethereal Rhapsody mural filling the walls and ceiling of the Monon tunnel
Finished tunnel: walls and ceiling
City Center Drive tunnel, afterCity Center Drive tunnel, before
Before and after
Close detail of the mural ceiling with flowing clouds and musical forms
Ceiling detail
Students hand-painting the lower walls of the tunnel
Paint-by-number day: students paint the reachable zone
Current in Carmel print article headlined Wander With Wonder
Current in Carmel, print edition, April 2021

2022–2023 · Monon Greenway, 116th Street tunnel · Carmel, Indiana · 3,680 sq ft

Back Home Again

Role: Planning and art-to-mural production, O.N.E. Consulting. I worked with Carmel High School graduate Emily Garnes to turn her graphic design of Indiana-native plants and animals across four seasons into a full-scale tunnel mural. "We've worked daily with the artist to design a catalog of native wildlife and plant life."

Press: Current in Carmel

Back Home Again mural with autumn trees and wildlife lining the tunnel walls
Finished tunnel: autumn into winter
116th Street tunnel, after116th Street tunnel, before
Before and after
Winter section of the mural with a cardinal, deer, and bare trees
Winter detail

Hospitality interior · Hotel Carmichael · Carmel, Indiana

Feinstein's at Hotel Carmichael

Role: Concept to install, O.N.E. Consulting / MuralPro™. A 1920s Deco stairwell mural (art: Jordan Elsey) and a music-themed entry for Feinstein's, turning raw concrete and blank panels into an arrival sequence.

Feinstein's 1920s Deco stairwell mural, afterFeinstein's 1920s Deco stairwell mural, before
1920s Deco stairwell
Feinstein's entry doors and panels, afterFeinstein's entry doors and panels, before
Feinstein's entry

2016–2021 · Shepherd Insurance · Carmel, Indiana

Building an in-house agency

As Director of Marketing & Communications, I pitched, founded, and led the firm's first in-house creative and marketing agency and hired three direct reports. I directed brand assimilation for 15+ acquisitions as the firm doubled revenue (2017–2019) and grew to 30+ locations, designed and published the 2018 marketing keynote, and built Shep Cal and the ShepStore ordering portal for 30+ offices ($250K+ in recurring annual overhead reductions).

2019–present · O.N.E. Consulting LLC / MuralPro™

Systems behind the work

I created the Paint by Number Experience™, a printed mural system that lets students and residents hand-paint finished artwork, and the O.N.E. Artist Registry™, a multi-artist model with shared design, prep, and QC standards. In October 2026 I led an AI-agent sprint that launched yourmuralpro.com and staged two brand sites.

Career arc

  1. 2010–2013
    Indiana University Bloomington

    Coursework in entrepreneurship, journalism, telecommunications, and strategic communications.

    H.Y.P.E.: philanthropic fashion shows involving 13+ university organizations.

  2. 2013–2016
    WAV LLC, Owner

    Brand executions and exterior visual identity across 40+ client sites.

  3. 2014–2016
    SERV LLC, Co-founder
  4. 2016–2021
    Shepherd Insurance, Director of Marketing & Communications; later Commercial Insurance & Marketing Consultant

    Founded and led the firm's first in-house marketing agency.

  5. 2019–2021
    IMCA, Board Member & Strategic Advisor

    Conceived and helped commercialize the industry's first professional certification for insurance marketers.

  6. 2019–now
    O.N.E. Consulting LLC, Founder & CEO

    Creative strategy and large-format production. Ethereal Rhapsody (2021), Back Home Again (2022–2023), Feinstein's at Hotel Carmichael.

  7. 2021
    GoGiles

    Short insurtech consulting engagement.

  8. 2022
    MuralPro™

    Experiential mural studio under O.N.E. Consulting.

Also: Co-founder, ROM Media. Credential: Commercial Lines Coverage Specialist (CLCS), The Hartford.

Resumes

Contact

johnmichael@oneconsulting.one

johnmichaelthomaspolley@gmail.com

317-213-2362 · LinkedIn